This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, Blaq Vixen Beauty may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Blue is the shade that never really leaves the red carpet — a navy mani on Ashanti, a cobalt liner on a summer night, a true-blue shadow that makes brown eyes look like they were lit from inside. This list started back in 2013 with a single entry, and it’s finally getting the full twenty it always promised.
1. Essie — Butler Please
Ashanti carries around a bottle of Essie’s Butler Please in her purse. (source: Essence, June 25, 2013, “What’s In Ashanti’s Makeup Bag?”)
2026 update: Butler Please is still sold — $9.99 at Target, $10.00 at Ulta (checked November 21, 2026). Thirteen years on, the soft periwinkle-blue is still in Essie’s line, and it’s still the kind of shade that looks polished on every skin tone without trying too hard.
The 2026 Completion
[The draft stopped after entry No. 1, so the nineteen picks below are a 2026 completion — researched and price-checked November 21, 2026. They are not the draft’s original 2013 entries. Prices are as listed at the named retailer on that date. ★ marks a Black-owned brand.]
Nails
2. OPI Nail Lacquer in Russian Navy — $11.99, Target. The classic deep navy. One coat is sheer enough for the office; two coats is a true midnight blue that reads almost black in dim light and unmistakably blue in the sun.
3. Essie Nail Polish in You Do Blue — $9.99, Target. A bright, true blue with a cream finish. This is the one to reach for when you want the color to be the whole statement.
4. Essie Nail Polish in Less Is Norse — $9.99, Target. A muted, dusty blue-grey — softer than navy, cooler than sky blue. Beautiful on deep skin, and the kind of shade that works with everything in your closet.
5. Essie expressie in Feel The Hype — $9.99, Target. A slate blue from the quick-dry expressie line, made for when you want a blue mani in the time it takes your coffee to cool.
6. OPI Nail Lacquer in Don’t Over Ink It — $11.99, opi.com. A navy shimmer that catches the light without going glittery. Dressy enough for a night out, quiet enough for every day.
7. Sally Hansen Insta-Dri in Midnight Drive (#493) — $5.99, Target. The budget pick of the bunch, and it dries in about sixty seconds. A deep, inky navy that looks far more expensive than six dollars.
8. Olive & June Nail Polish in OMG — $9.99, Target. A deep indigo — blue with a whisper of purple — that stays sophisticated instead of going costume-y.
9. Olive & June Gel Nail Polish in Suited — $11.99, Target. A deep navy in the gel formula, for up to three weeks of salon-quality wear at home. The gel line is HEMA-free and 15-free.
Liners and shadows
10. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Chaos — $23, urbandecay.com. The cult cobalt. Creamy enough to smudge into a smoky eye, and it sets without budging. On deep skin, Chaos reads as a true, electric blue instead of washing out.
11. NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Stick in Blue Trip — $8.99, Target. A waterproof liner stick in a vivid blue that stays put through heat and humidity — the drugstore answer to a blue wing.
12. NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liquid Liner in Sapphire — $10.79, Target. The liquid version for a sharper wing. Sapphire is a rich jewel blue with a matte finish.
13. Maybelline Tattoo Studio Sharpenable Gel Pencil in Striking Navy — $8.99, Target. A matte navy gel pencil with 36-hour wear. Softer than black on the lash line, but still defines the eye — the everyday blue.
14. Maybelline Tattoo Studio Sharpenable Gel Pencil in Galactic Cobalt — $8.99, Target. The bolder sister to Striking Navy: a true matte cobalt for when you want the blue to be the point.
15. e.l.f. No Budge Shadow Stick in Blue Steel — $6.00, Target. A six-dollar metallic blue shadow stick you can swipe on and blend with a finger. Blue Steel is a cool, steely blue that flatters deep skin without looking ashy.
Mascara
16. L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara in Cobalt Blue — $11.99, lorealparisusa.com. Blue mascara is the quietest way into this trend: it reads almost black at a glance, then flashes blue in the light. The Voluminous formula is the same buildable, clump-resistant one that has been a drugstore staple for years.
The splurge liner
17. Dior Diorshow 24H Stylo in 296 Matte Blue — $36, Neiman Marcus. A waterproof retractable pencil in a very dark navy matte, with a built-in smudger and sharpener. The luxury pick for a blue eye that lasts all day and all night.
Palettes and multi-use paints
18. ★ Juvia’s Place The Zulu Eyeshadow Palette — $20–$25, Ulta / juviasplace.com. Nine wildly pigmented shades inspired by the arts of the Ndebele people of South Africa, including a vivid turquoise and a deep blue. Juvia’s Place pigment shows up true on deep skin — no white cast, no chalkiness. (Price varies by retailer: $20 at Ulta, $25 on the brand’s own site.)
19. ★ Danessa Myricks Beauty Colorfix 24-Hour Cream Color in a blue shade — $22, Sephora. The multi-use cream pigment that works as eyeshadow, liner, and lip color in one tube. The line runs to more than sixty shades, including bold sky blues — pick the blue that speaks to you, and one tube will do eyes, cheeks, and lips.
20. ★ The Crayon Case Box of Crayons iShadow Palette — $30, The Crayon Case. Eighteen rainbow-bright shadows named after crayons, including a true “Blue” — from Black-owned brand The Crayon Case, founded by Supa Cent. A whole spectrum in one box, and the blue is as loud as you want it to be.
That’s twenty — one from 2013, nineteen from 2026. Blue isn’t a trend that comes and goes; it’s a staple that keeps finding new ways to show up. Whether you start with Ashanti’s Butler Please or go straight for the cobalt liner, there’s a blue here with your name on it.
Stay true to the vixen in you. — Lakish