This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, Blaq Vixen Beauty may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Naomi Campbell wears ST1 Brun Adore from the Lancome Hypnose Star Eyes Palette.
That’s where this list started back in 2013 — one look, one palette, and a title that promised ten eyeliners. The other nine never got written. So here they are, finished the way this list always meant to be: one classic, and nine more worth trying now.
1. Lancôme Hypnose Star Eyes Palette — ST1 Brun Adore
Naomi’s look is the anchor of this list: a soft, smoky brown eye built from the Lancôme Hypnose Star Eyes Palette in ST1 Brun Adore. Brown is the quiet workhorse of liner looks on deep skin — it defines without the harshness of jet black, and it warms up every skin tone it touches. If black liner has ever felt too stark on you, brown is your answer.
2026 update
The Hypnôse palette line lives on: the Lancôme Hypnôse 5-Color Eyeshadow Palette is still sold at $65 on lancome-usa.com, in colour families like French Nude and Taupe Craze. But I could not verify that the 2013 “Star Eyes” edition — or the ST1 Brun Adore shade itself — is still available. If you want the same effect today, reach for the Hypnôse 5-Color Palette in Taupe Craze ($65, Lancôme), or any warm brown palette you already own.
2026 completion: the other nine
The nine picks below are a 2026 completion of this list — researched and price-checked on November 21, 2026. They were not part of the original 2013 draft. Prices are as found on the named retailer’s site that day. ★ marks a Black-owned brand.
2. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner — $25, Ulta
The winged-liner classic. A fine brush tip, waterproof wear, and a line that stays put from morning to midnight. If you only buy one liquid liner, this is the one most artists reach for first.
3. NYX Epic Ink Liner — $9, Ulta
The budget wing. A flexible brush tip and true waterproof wear for nine dollars — the closest thing to Stila’s precision at a drugstore price, and the one to hand a friend who is just learning to wing it.
4. Fenty Beauty Flyliner Longwear Liquid Eyeliner — $24, Ulta
Rihanna’s liner, built for a sharp, clean wing in one stroke. The triangular grip makes it easy to hold steady, and the pigment is deep and true — a real contender for the best black liner on the market.
5. ★ Danessa Myricks Infinite Chrome Waterproof Micropencil Eyeliner in Charoite — $22, Sephora
A waterproof micropencil in a rich, multidimensional shade — Charoite is a deep violet-leaning tone that reads as soft definition on deep skin rather than a flat black line. Danessa Myricks is Black-owned, and this pencil is the one to reach for when you want colour that still looks like liner.
6. ★ Juvia’s Place i Line, i Define Pen Eyeliner — $13, Amazon
A pen liner from a Black-owned brand, at a price that makes it easy to try. Precise, dark, and built for the kind of clean line this list is all about.
7. ★ Pat McGrath Labs Perma Precision Liquid Eyeliner — $36, patmcgrath.com
The luxury wing. Pat McGrath’s liner lays down a velvety, intensely black line with a brush tip that forgives a shaky hand. Pat McGrath Labs is Black-owned, and this is the splurge pick of the list — the one for a night out, a photo shoot, or the day you want your liner to be the whole look.
8. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil in Perversion — $23, Ulta
The pencil that started a thousand smoky eyes. Perversion is the blackest black in the range, creamy enough to glide without tugging, and it sets down for up to 16 hours of wear. Smudge it with a brush for smoke, or keep the line sharp for definition.
9. Maybelline Tattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner — $8.99, Target
A gel pencil that behaves like a liquid — smooth, pigmented, and waterproof, with a twist-up tip that never needs sharpening. The drugstore workhorse for tightlining and waterline definition.
10. L’Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail 16HR Eyeliner Pencil — $9.99, Target
Sixteen hours of wear for under ten dollars. A mechanical gel pencil that holds its line through heat, humidity, and a long day — the everyday pick for when you want your liner to outlast everything else on your face.
How to pick your liner
- New to wings? Start with a pen — NYX Epic Ink ($9) or Juvia’s Place i Line, i Define ($13). The brush tip does half the work.
- Want smoke, not sharp? Reach for a pencil — Urban Decay 24/7 in Perversion ($23) or Maybelline Tattoo Studio ($8.99) — and smudge before it sets.
- Want colour without committing? Danessa Myricks Infinite Chrome in Charoite ($22) gives you depth with dimension.
- Want the deepest black? Stila Stay All Day ($25) or Pat McGrath Perma Precision ($36), depending on your budget.
Stay true to the vixen in you. — Lakish